Doing the Electric Slide

There are few topics more complicated than electricity regulation.  There are also few subjects which require more government "sunshine."  Otherwise, consumers are helpless before the ability of a monopolistic utility to raise prices (and its profits) literally at will. 
 
One of the great Democrats of the last century -- State Senator Henry Howell of Norfolk -- got his start by taking on the utilities.  His slogan?  "Keep the big boys honest."
 
Ten years ago, it was predicted that the electricity market would de-regulate, allowing consumers to select the best provider for their homes and businesses.  That movement flopped.  In fact, California literally "lost power" in the wake of deregulation.  It solved that problem in a novel way -- its citizens learned to use less power in their daily lives (and today its kwH per person ration is the lowest in the U.S.).
 
Virginia also passed a deregulation statute in 1999.  That fizzled as no new providers entered the market. 
 
In 2007, the General Assembly is ending deregulation.  But its proposed solution (SB 1416) does little for Virginia consumers.  Instead, it permits Dominion to "lock in" profits at pre-determined levels which are intentionally inexplicable to the average voter (or average legislator).   Read the bill yourself if you don't believe me. 
 
I'm not smart enough to know whether the benchmarks are reasonable but I do know this -- it is not the job of the Assembly to set profit levels for a privately-owned company.
 
There is a better alternative.  Prior to deregulation, Virginia used a "cost-based" regulation method, where the utility presents its costs to the State Corporation Commission for approval.  The independent Commission evaluated the costs and projected profits and compares them with other states.  They then set the rates for Virginia consumers. 
 
Why didn't anyone fight this 35-page bill?  Who has the time to even read it!
 
Virginia needs a consumer watchdog in Richmond to protect ordinary rate payers.  (It should be the Attorney General -- but that's another story).   Many states, especially those in the West where water and electricity are scarce, have a state consumer advocate monitoring these issues.  Without some professional help in Richmond, Virginia consumers are literally at the mercy of the powerful utility lobby.

Chap

 del.icio.us  Stumbleupon  Technorati  Digg 

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • Trackbacks are closed for this entry.
Comments

  • 3/13/2007 4:45 PM The Downstairs Captain wrote:
    I'm enjoying the blog, and doing my best to avoid politically indelicate comments. Suffice it to say that one need only look to California's experience of electricity deregulation in order to go screaming in the other direction.

    Does the campaign staff still keep frozen pizza in the basement?
  • 3/14/2007 3:03 PM Anonymous wrote:
    Downstairs Captain:

    Good to hear from you. Yeah, my wife threw the campaign out of the basement after kid #3 came along. I do still keep frozen pizza there.

    Keep the comments PG on the blog. I don't want all the opposition researchers to have to use a dictionary.
  • 3/14/2007 3:05 PM Chap wrote:
    that was me, of course
  • 3/14/2007 4:47 PM Walker wrote:
    Chap, I'm glad to hear your concern regarding the Dominion situation.

    I work with Virginians for Sensible Energy Policies (VSEP), a coalition of local groups, electric customers, families, farmers, workers and citizens of all ages. We have been closely following the re-regulation debate with great concern as Dominion is attempting to rush this bill through void of any public input since not even one public hearing was held. We are also particularly concerned with Dominion's proposal to build a 500,000-volt, 15 story, transmission line through the heart of Virginia. As we have noted, this proposal is both irresponsible and unnecessary. In fact, VSEP has been asking Dominion for their studies that apparently prove the need for such a line, yet they refuse to share any of this information.

    You may be curious to see our latest add that is running in papers throughout the state this week. The ad highlights some of the points I raised and even more. Here it is,

    http://www.energypolicies.org/documents/MiddleBurgE_ShiningtheLight.pdf

    Thanks.
  • 4/15/2007 4:49 PM Chris Porter wrote:
    Yeah, but you could have helped kill dereg in 2004 by voting against SB 651. You voted for the bill, which kept "dereg" alive for another three years.

    http://leg1.state.va.us/cgi-bin/legp504.exe?041+vot+HV1725+SB0651
  • 9/10/2007 6:45 PM Aron wrote:
    Good blog! intresting work.
Leave a comment

Comments are closed.